Wrist Pain After a Fall: The Fracture That Hides on X-Ray | Form & Function MD
No Big Deal or Red Flag

Wrist Pain After a Fall: The Fracture That Hides on X-Ray

Form & Function MD · Dr. Ben, MD

You trip, catch yourself on an outstretched hand, and the wrist aches. Most of these are sprains. The one I don't want missed is a fracture of the scaphoid, a small bone on the thumb side of the wrist.

The scaphoid has two problems. Fractures there often don't show on the first X-ray. And its blood supply is poor, so a fracture that isn't protected can fail to heal.

Find the snuffbox

Spread your thumb out to the side. The small hollow that appears at the base of the thumb, on the back of the wrist, is the "anatomical snuffbox." The scaphoid sits right under it. Tenderness when you press there after a fall is the classic warning sign.

No Big Deal
  • Mild, diffuse soreness across the wrist
  • Normal grip strength
  • No swelling
  • No tenderness when you press the snuffbox
  • Steadily improving over several days
Red Flag
  • Tenderness right in the snuffbox
  • Swelling on the thumb side of the wrist
  • Pain with gripping or pinching
  • Any of these even after a normal X-ray
  • A visible deformity: that's a different fracture, and it needs care now
A normal X-ray doesn't clear a tender snuffbox. That's one of the first things I teach residents.

What happens next

Standard approach
  • If the snuffbox is tender but the X-ray is normal, the wrist is splinted as if it were broken.
  • Imaging is repeated in about 10–14 days, or an MRI is done sooner to settle the question.
  • A confirmed fracture that's well aligned is often treated in a cast. Displaced fractures, or those near the top of the bone, may need surgery.
  • The risk of skipping this: a fracture that doesn't heal, which can lead to wrist arthritis years later.
Bottom line
Wrist pain after a fall that's centered on the thumb side, especially with snuffbox tenderness, deserves an exam and an X-ray, and a splint if there's any doubt. A week of protection is a small price for avoiding a non-healing fracture.

This article is for education, not a diagnosis. If something here sounds like you, see a physician who can examine you.

  1. Phillips TG, et al. Diagnosis and management of scaphoid fractures. Am Fam Physician. 2004;70(5):879–884.
  2. Mallee WH, et al. Computed tomography versus magnetic resonance imaging versus bone scintigraphy for clinically suspected scaphoid fractures. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2015;(6):CD010023.